Phenacolepas pararabica J.M.J. Christiaens, 1988
Plesiothyreus parmophoroides (FOSSIL) (A.E.M. Cossmann, 1885 †)
Phenacolepas peelae J.M.J. Christiaens, 1989
Phenacolepas planata T. Habe, 1961
Plesiothyreus pliocenicus (FOSSIL) (C. Chirli, 2004 †)
Phenacolepas pulchella (C.E. Lischke, 1871)
Phenacolepas puntarenae (O.A.L. Mörch, 1860)
Phenacolepas radiata M.M. Schepman, 1908
Phenacolepas reticulata K.H.J. Thiele, 1909
Plesiothyreus rushii (W.H. Dall, 1889)
Phenacolepas sagittifer (A.A. Gould, 1852)
Phenacolepas scobinata (A.A. Gould, 1859)
Phenacolepas senta C. Hedley, 1899
Olgasolaris tollmanni L.A. Beck, 1992
Shinkailepas tufari L.A. Beck, 1992
Phenacolepas unguiformis (A.A. Gould, 1859)